‘Busy Work Trap’ Drains Productivity, Says HR Expert Shaqeem Akbar-Downey

HR vendors should note that fragmented focus and constant task switching, not lack of effort, are the primary drivers of poor workplace performance, according to marketing professional Shaqeem Akbar-Downey.

Found this article helpful?

Share it with your network and spread the knowledge!

‘Busy Work Trap’ Drains Productivity, Says HR Expert Shaqeem Akbar-Downey

Businesses are moving faster than ever, with meetings filling calendars and messages arriving constantly. Yet many companies still struggle to improve performance in measurable ways. According to Shaqeem Akbar-Downey, a marketing and advertising management professional based in Toronto, the problem is not always effort—it is direction.

“A lot of teams are busy from morning to evening, but nothing important actually moves forward,” Akbar-Downey says. “People confuse motion with progress.” He refers to this issue as the “busy work trap.”

Research from the American Psychological Association shows that multitasking and constant task switching can reduce productivity by as much as 40 percent. Another study from the University of California, Irvine found that workers can take more than 20 minutes to fully regain focus after interruptions. Despite these findings, many businesses continue operating in environments built around constant reaction, Akbar-Downey notes.

One business owner recently reviewed a full workday with staff after noticing a decline in performance. “We realized we had spent hours replying to messages and discussing ideas,” Akbar-Downey explains. “At the end of the day, almost none of the core work had actually been completed.” The issue was not laziness but fragmented focus.

Busy work creates the appearance of momentum—fast replies, endless updates, constant meetings—but visible activity often replaces meaningful execution. Akbar-Downey points to similarities between business and sports training. “In youth sports, you see players running around constantly but avoiding the drills that actually improve performance,” he says. “Businesses do the same thing. Teams stay active but avoid the deeper work that requires concentration.”

Constant task switching is one of the biggest causes of sloppy execution. A campaign manager recently described reviewing marketing performance while simultaneously responding to multiple conversations, leading to missed details and incorrect information sent to clients. “Everybody felt productive because they were moving fast,” Akbar-Downey says. “But speed without structure usually creates more cleanup later.” He believes many businesses now operate in a permanent state of urgency where every issue feels equally important, destroying focus.

To combat this, Akbar-Downey recommends a structured approach built around consistency and measurable output. His recommendations include protecting uninterrupted work blocks each day, reducing unnecessary internal communication, tracking completed outcomes instead of visible activity, building repeatable systems for reviews and follow-up, and stopping changes before processes have time to work. One team he observed introduced fixed review periods each morning before calls and meetings began. “Within weeks, mistakes dropped because people finally had time to think properly,” he says.

Research from Stanford University has shown that productivity declines sharply once people consistently work excessive hours, with error rates rising while accuracy drops. Akbar-Downey believes many businesses have mistaken exhaustion for commitment. “Hustle culture made people think constant pressure equals performance,” he says. “Usually it just creates sloppy work.” Instead, he believes stable routines create stronger long-term results, as seen in youth sports programmes where repetitive habits often matter more than emotional motivation. “Consistency beats intensity most of the time,” he adds.

As businesses continue to operate in fast-moving environments, the pressure to remain constantly active has increased. Akbar-Downey believes companies that learn to protect focus and structure will gain a major advantage. “Most performance problems don’t start because people lack talent,” he says. “They start because systems break down under distraction.” His advice is simple: focus less on looking busy and more on building repeatable systems that hold up under pressure.

Human Resources Editorial Team

Human Resources Editorial Team

@burstable-hr

Burstable News™ is a hosted content solution that empowers HR teams and recruitment marketers to strengthen their employer brand and search visibility without draining internal resources. By automatically populating career sites and corporate blogs with fresh, unique, and brand-aligned business news, it enhances AIO and SEO strategies to attract top talent. The platform requires no developer implementation, ensuring HR leaders can maintain a dynamic, E-E-A-T compliant digital presence that establishes industry authority with zero administrative overhead.